© 2024 Hawaiʻi Public Radio
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Trump Versus News Media Lands In Court

President Trump gets into a heated exchange with CNN chief White House correspondent Jim Acosta during a postelection press conference Nov. 7.
Jim Watson
AFP/Getty Images
President Trump gets into a heated exchange with CNN chief White House correspondent Jim Acosta during a postelection press conference Nov. 7.

Updated 4:27 p.m. ET

A battle between the White House and the press lands in federal court Thursday.

CNN filed a lawsuit against President Trump on Tuesday, asking that the White House be ordered to restore the press pass held by its lead reporter on the beat, Jim Acosta. The case will be heard Thursday in U.S. District Court in Washington, D.C., by Judge Timothy J. Kelly, who was appointed by Trump to the bench.

The White House yanked Acosta's press pass after a testy exchange with the president at a news conference last Wednesday. Initially, press secretary Sarah Sanders, relying on a video that had been slowed down and zoomed in on, alleged that Acosta had "plac[ed] his hands" on an aide who was trying to retrieve the microphone from Acosta at the press conference.

Later, the White House dropped that justification and said Acosta had "failed to treat the White House and the office of the presidency with respect."

CNN went to court seeking an immediate restoration of Acosta's press pass. It says that pulling the pass was a violation of the First Amendment guarantee of a free press and that doing so is essentially a way for the president to pick and choose who may cover the White House and to punish journalists for publishing material critical of the president.

Trump was asked Wednesday in an interview with The Daily Caller, a conservative news outlet, whether he thought his administration would win.

"I don't know," he said, "we should. ... We'll see how the court rules. Is it freedom of the press when somebody comes in and starts screaming questions and won't sit down?"

The CNN suit also relied on the constitution's guarantee to due process of law, and a federal law, the Administrative Procedures Act, that establishes rules for administrative actions, like this one.

In the past, there have been occasional flare-ups between the White House and the press corps over the qualifications of individual applicants for White House passes. In 1977, a lower court ruled against the Secret Service for pulling the pass of a reporter without establishing and following standards for doing that.

But the Acosta case appears to be unprecedented. Trump has repeatedly criticized CNN's coverage of the White House, characterizing it as "fake news," which he did again at the Nov. 7 press conference.

"I'll tell you what, CNN should be ashamed of itself, having you work for them," Trump told Acosta during the televised news conference. "You are a rude, terrible person" and when "you report fake news, which CNN does a lot, you are the enemy of the people."

Two days later, after Acosta's pass had been pulled, Trump also suggested that he might revoke the press passes of "others, too."

CNN's lawsuit is supported by a variety of other news organizations, including Fox News, the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press and the White House Correspondents' Association, which issued a statement of strong support.

Justice Department lawyers, in court papers, defended the president's position. They contended that the administration has "the same broad discretion" to grant or pull passes from journalists assigned to cover the White House as it has to grant interviews to call on journalists at press conferences.

And they resurrected, by inference, that Acosta had acted improperly at the Nov. 7 press conference, contending that he "was disrupting press proceedings," as "is evident from the video he has proffered."

CNN has some 50 other employees who still have White House passes, the president's lawyers said. And "even if" CNN could show some First Amendment harm "in the abstract," Acosta is free to "practice his profession and report on the White House" without the access that a White House press pass provides.

Copyright 2021 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

Domenico Montanaro is NPR's senior political editor/correspondent. Based in Washington, D.C., his work appears on air and online delivering analysis of the political climate in Washington and campaigns. He also helps edit political coverage.
Nina Totenberg is NPR's award-winning legal affairs correspondent. Her reports air regularly on NPR's critically acclaimed newsmagazines All Things Considered, Morning Edition, and Weekend Edition.
More from Hawai‘i Public Radio