Alleged Nazi Labor Camp Guard Deported To Germany

Aug 21, 2018
Originally published on August 22, 2018 3:17 am

Updated at 9 a.m. ET Wednesday

U.S. officials say a 95-year-old former Nazi labor camp guard named Jakiw Palij who lied about his wartime work when he immigrated to the United States has been deported to Germany.

Palij, who lived in Queens in New York City, was investigated and denaturalized more than a decade ago. His deportation was ordered in 2004. But for years, no country would take him in.

On Monday, he was sent to Germany, according to the State Department. The Department of Justice says Palij is the 68th Nazi removed from the U.S.

Palij has denied that he worked at a camp and has said he served as a Nazi guard only because his family was threatened.

In a statement, the White House praised the work of administration agencies, particularly Immigrations and Customs Enforcement, in deporting Palij.

"Palij's removal sends a strong message: The United States will not tolerate those who facilitated Nazi crimes and other human rights violations, and they will not find a safe haven on American soil," press secretary Sarah Sanders said in an overnight statement.

Palij was born in Piadyki, Poland (which is now part of Ukraine), the Justice Department says, and he became a U.S. citizen in 1957.

Peter Black, who worked for the Department of Justice and as a historian at the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, served as an expert witness in Palij's case. The museum confirms that Palij was a guard at the Trawniki labor camp in Nazi-occupied Poland and that he was among those who provided the manpower to "Operation Reinhard," the plan to kill 2 million Jews living in Poland.

Black tells NPR that he first discovered Palij's name at an archive in Prague, which opened to Western researchers after Czechoslovakia's Velvet Revolution. He and a colleague, Elizabeth Black, were poring over those records when they found lists of names with military IDs.

"We recognized right away that this was the unit that operated after the Germans withdrew from Trawniki," Black says. "We could tell that the men listed in these records were Trawniki trained guards ... and on all three sets of the rosters, Jakiw Palij's name appears."

Palij admitted to officials that he was trained at an SS training camp in Trawniki, which was next to the labor camp, in the spring of 1943, according to court documents.

But the documents didn't say what he did after his training.

"There's a big gap in the historical record," Eli Rosenbaum, former director of the Department of Justice's Office of Special Investigations, tells NPR. And Palij wasn't talking: "Mr. Palij took the Fifth Amendment and would not cooperate in the search for truth in his case."

So Black and other historians focused on what happened during training at Trawniki. They demonstrated that recruits such as Palij were routinely ordered to take shifts guarding the forced labor camp next door. They were armed and told to shoot anyone who attempted to escape, Black says.

On Nov. 3, 1943, approximately 6,000 Jewish prisoners at that camp — men, women and children — were shot to death in a single day.

The Justice Department wrote in a statement that it was "one of the largest single massacres of the Holocaust."

"By helping to prevent the escape of these prisoners during his service at Trawniki, Palij played an indispensable role in ensuring that they later met their tragic fate at the hands of the Nazis," the department wrote.

The Trawniki camp was dissolved by the Nazis in 1944, the Holocaust Museum says. By that time, according to court documents, Palij had already been sent to train with SS troops for combat.

When Palij immigrated to the U.S. in 1949, he told officials he had spent the war working on farms and in a factory.

Decades later, when confronted about his past, Palij told investigators that "everybody lied" on their visas, The Associated Press reports.

The U.S. cannot criminally prosecute World War II crimes that were carried out overseas, but Palij was held responsible for lying on his immigration paperwork.

In 2003, Palij told The New York Times that he served the Nazis only under duress and maintained that he guarded bridges and rivers, not Jewish prisoners.

"We knew they would kill me and my family if I refused," he told the Times. "I did it to save their lives."

Rabbi Marvin Hier, founder of the Simon Wiesenthal Center, told the Times that this was a frequent and unconvincing line of defense. "To work at those camps, you had to be eager to be there," he told the newspaper. "They only took people they knew were loyal and brutal and not sympathetic to pleas of the inmates."

Court records show that although Palij admitted to being trained at Trawniki and acknowledged there was a "Jewish labor camp next door," he questioned the strength of the evidence against him. (At one point, he called the government's case against him "an expression of opinion about history.")

His name appeared on multiple SS rosters, and an acquaintance recalled seeing him among the Trawniki recruits. There was no "direct evidence" that he guarded the Jewish labor camp but it was sufficient to demonstrate that so was among the duties of guards at Trawniki, a judge concluded — especially since Palij did not present any specific argument or evidence suggesting he was innocent.

The judge acknowledged that Nazis might have threatened some men who then enlisted with them, though some guards describe joining voluntarily. But it wouldn't change Palij's case either way, the judge said.

"His employment at Trawniki, however involuntary or removed from the direct brutalization of Jews, rendered him ineligible for an immigrant visa," District Judge Allyne Ross wrote in 2003.

But after Palij was ordered to be deported, no country agreed to take him in.

"This is a very common problem," Rosenbaum told NPR. "We have been working hard to persuade governments in Europe to relent ever since the late '70s. And one of the tragic consequences of that refusal is that nine Nazi perpetrators ... died here [in the U.S.], all between 2005 and 2015."

Palij seemed confident he'd have the same fate. When he spoke to the Times in 2003, he said, "What will they do? Shoot me? Put me in the electric chair?" he asked. "Where are they going to deport me to? What country is going to take an 80-year-old man in poor health?"

While the U.S. government put pressure on European governments, Palij "continued living in limbo in the two-story, red brick home in Queens he shared with his wife, Maria," the AP writes. Palij's wife has since died, according to U.S. officials. "His continued presence there outraged the Jewish community, attracting frequent protests over the years that featured such chants as 'your neighbor is a Nazi!' "

For years, students at Rambam Mesivta, a Jewish high school on Long Island, held protests outside Palij's house.

Rosenbaum said Tuesday that the protests by those high school students "helped ensure that the public never forgot this case."

Last year, some members of Congress from New York wrote to then-Secretary of State Rex Tillerson to ask for his "personal intervention" to push for Palij's deportation.

The U.S. ambassador to Germany, Richard Grenell, says he had recently been raising the question of Palij's deportation in every meeting he had in Germany, based in part on President Trump's particular interest in the case. After a new government was installed in Berlin, there was "new energy" for the negotiations, he says.

Palij landed in Dusseldorf early Tuesday. He has been taken to a home for the elderly in Germany, according to Reuters.

"Given his age and questions over his health and also a possible lack of proof, it is unclear whether German authorities will attempt to prosecute the stateless pensioner," the wire service writes.

Copyright 2018 NPR. To see more, visit


An accused Nazi guard has been deported to Germany. This comes after many years of work by the U.S. government to investigate him and then to find a country to take him. NPR's Camila Domonoske reports.

CAMILA DOMONOSKE, BYLINE: When Jakiw Palij came to the U.S. in 1949, he said he spent the years of World War II working on farms and at a factory. For decades, he lived a quiet life in New York. Then in 1990, a group of American historians traveled to Prague to look at a trove of documents. They were working for the Office of Special Investigations, or OSI, trying to track down Nazis hiding in the United States. They found typewritten lists of names of Nazi guards. Peter Black was one of those historians.

PETER BLACK: And on all three sets of the rosters Jakiw Palij's name appears.

DOMONOSKE: The OSI spent more than a decade building a case against Palij. Palij admitted that he'd been trained at the Trawniki camp in Poland, his home country. The camp provided manpower for a Nazi program to kill the 2 million Jews in occupied Poland and steal their property. But the documents didn't say what he did after his training, and Palij wouldn't answer questions. So Black and his fellow historians used documents and testimony to prove that Trawniki men were assigned to guard a neighboring forced labor camp as part of their training.

BLACK: And had received orders to shoot anyone who was trying to escape.

DOMONOSKE: Eli Rosenbaum used to be the director of OSI. Now he works in human rights at the Department of Justice. He says Trawniki guards like Palij kept Jewish prisoners in captivity.

ELI ROSENBAUM: And in the end, on November 3, 1943, in an all-day shooting spree, men, women and children - up to 6,000 of them were murdered.

DOMONOSKE: A judge ordered Palij deported in 2004, but the United States couldn't find a country to take him in. Rosenbaum says that has been a common problem after the Department of Justice finds Nazi perpetrators.

ROSENBAUM: In nine of those cases, European governments refused to readmit. And they died here.

DOMONOSKE: Palij kept living in Queens in a two-story brick house, but his life wasn't so quiet anymore. Year after year, protesters came to his house.


UNIDENTIFIED PROTESTERS: (Chanting) Your neighbor is a Nazi. Your neighbor is a Nazi.

DOMONOSKE: That's from video The Jerusalem Post published last year. In 2003, Palij spoke to The New York Times about his case. He scoffed at the idea of deportation. What country is going to take an 80-year-old man in poor health, he asked. Now Palij is 95. He landed in Dusseldorf this morning. Camila Domonoske, NPR News.

(SOUNDBITE OF BLUE STATES' "FIGHT THE DYING DAY") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.